Find Me A Place to Begin

The Steve Jobs Biography

This review from Amazon sums it up: 

This new, highly-anticipated bio is reasonably comprehensive in scope, but written in a plodding, subjectively fawning fashion that undercuts its impact. Mr. Isaacson doesn’t hail from the technology world, and it shows; his feel for the real importance of Jobs’ accomplishments is largely constrained to social impact (of the fuzzy, gee-whiz sort) rather than crucial areas of interface, functionality and convergence. Why do Apple’s products really work? What impact will they have on how we interact with the digital world, tomorrow and after? Isaacson has no idea. All he seems to know is that ‘simplicity’ is good, and that ‘design’ is more than skin deep. And that the little things matter. Millions upon millions of people already know that; the opportunity missed here is to go deep on the subject, and unpack it. That doesn’t happen here, because the writer is out of his element.

Apart from that, we learn that Jobs was basically an ass, and that he cried a lot when he didn’t get his way. It’s implied that he carried a narcissistic disorder, but that’s never really explored — to the book’s detriment, as psychiatric context is pretty important to understand how a comprehensive tyrant could achieve so much, and improve the productivity and satisfaction of so many. 

The book is also overlong — a remarkable thing given the richness of the subject. It’s written almost as a sequential fact-finding report, rather than as a truly insightful look at a man and his work. We come away with the impression that strong-willed CEOs can do what they want, as long as they make money for shareholders and impart a sense of accomplishment (however painfully won) to their underlings. Not exactly a revelation, but it takes more than 600 pages for Isaacson to drive the point home.

I’m glad we have this bio, but I suspect someone will come along and write a much better treatment of Jobs’ life. For now, don’t expect to learn any larger truths about Jobs and his world; just enjoy the anecdotes, and prepare to make your own conclusions about the book’s fascinating subject.

(Source: amazon.com)